• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Our Spicy Book Club

Turning up the heat on book clubs, one steamy chapter at a time

  • Home
  • Spicy Book Reviews
  • Discussion Guides: Book Series
  • Discussion Guides: Standalone Books
  • Discussion Guides: Novellas
  • Show Search
Hide Search
This page may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Steffanie Holmes – Memoirs of a Garroter

Memoirs of a Garroter by Steffanie Holmes is the fourth installment in the Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries series.

At the time of publishing this guide, this story was available on Kindle Unlimited.

Here’s more about the book, along with our free Dirty Dozen downloadable discussion question guide for your spicy book club.

Book description

Murder is bad for business, especially when the hot local crime writer is garrotted between the shelves!

With grudging permission from Heathcliff, Mina Wilde has transformed Nevermore Bookshop. She’s running author events, hosting Quoth’s art show, and using her creative flair to attract more customers. But when crime writer Danny Sledge is murdered moments before his writing workshop, the bookshop goes from bustling to broke. No one in the village will set foot inside Nevermore.

What if the murderer is targeting the bookshop? What if it’s connected to Mina’s father and the mysterious room? All Mina knows is that if she doesn’t solve the crime soon, she can kiss her livelihood goodbye.

Add in a plague of locusts, an emotional school visit, and a magical visitor from the past, and poor Mina has her work cut out for her.

Luckily, she has Heathcliff, Morrie, and Quoth to help… that is – if they can keep their hands off her, or each other…

The Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries are what you get when all your book boyfriends come to life. Join a brooding antihero, a master criminal, a cheeky raven, and a heroine with a big heart (and an even bigger book collection) in this steamy reverse harem paranormal mystery series.

Click here to get Memoirs of a Garroter

Memoirs of a Garroter book club discussion guide

**PLEASE BE AWARE THAT THIS DISCUSSION QUESTION GUIDE MIGHT INCLUDE SPOILERS**

We’ve provided the Dirty Dozen below; twelve spicy and intriguing questions to spark discussion and help you uncover the spine-tingling depths of the story.

The Dirty Dozen

Foreplay – Warm Up Questions

1. What’s the overall spice level? 1 (Not Spicy) – 10 (Spiciest Thing I’ve Ever Read)?

2. How does the spice level compare to the other books we’ve read together?

3. The coffee machine line sets the tone for humor and obsession. What’s the quirkiest, most ridiculous “everyday object crush” you’ve ever had?

The Spicy Bits – Gettin’ Down and Dirty with the Plot

4. Would you ever be bold enough to ask for something as explicit as “suck on my nipples until I scream for mercy”? Or do you prefer your desires to be discovered without asking?

5. Is Mina’s mom just a selfish opportunist, or does she actually have ambition and hustle worth respecting?

6. That moment of possessiveness with wanting to stake your claim on someone in public; have you ever felt that primal surge? How did you handle it?

7. The “hardest path” conversation is really about navigating a polyamorous relationship. Do you think the struggle makes that kind of love stronger and more intentional, or is it just a way to avoid admitting how vulnerable it feels to love more than one person?

8. Imagine the “grandmother plot twist.” How would you react if your family revealed a hidden, supernatural secret about themselves?

9. If a character could leave their own story and become real, which one from your favorite books would you choose to cross over? What kind of chaos (or pleasure) would they bring to your world?

10. In the heat of the moment, Morrie promises no sleeping at all. What’s your ultimate fantasy getaway or bedroom setup, and which fictional (or real) lovers would you stock it with?

11. When Beverly confronts Angus and it’s revealed he’s the real threat, did you see it coming? What clues tipped you off, or were you completely blindsided by the killer being under our noses all along?

Aftercare – Final Thoughts

12. This book blurs the line between story and reality. If you could step into any book’s world for just one night, which one would you choose? Do you think you would come back the same?

Bonus: What questions do you have for the author? If you could dog-ear a page with a question for the author, what would it be?

Please feel free to use this post as a starting point for your spicy book club discussion questions and use the comments below to share your thoughts and insights about the book. You can also get a free downloadable copy of the discussion guide using the button below.

download the Dirty Dozen Questions

Click here to get Memoirs of a Garroter

Click here to get Kindle Unlimited

Written by:
Our Spicy Book Club
Published on:
January 18, 2026
Thoughts:
No comments yet

Categories: Book SeriesTags: Fantasy, Magic, Morally Gray MMC, Mystery, Nevermore Bookshop Mysteries Series, Paranormal Romance, Reverse Harem, Steffanie Holmes Books, Urban Fantasy, Why Choose

Reader Interactions

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Join our live spicy book club for The Things We Leave Unfinished on Feb 26 – click the cover for more details

Rebecca Yarros The Things We Leave Unfinished book cover

Search our site

Join the Our Spicy Book Club Facebook group

  • Facebook

Follow us on Goodreads & The StoryGraph

Our Spicy Book Club on Goodreads

Our Spicy Book Club on The StoryGraph

Get access to unlimited reading with Kindle Unlimited

Looking for a trope or theme?

Academia
Accidental Pregnancy
Adoption
Age Gap
Animal Companion
Antihero
Arranged Marriage
Artist
Audiobook Narration – Dual
Audiobook Narration – Duet
Audiobook Narration – Male
BDSM
Beach Read
Best Friend’s Brother
Best Friend’s Daughter
Best Friend’s Sister
Best Friend’s Son
Bi-Awakening
Billionaire
Bisexual
Bodyguard
Boss/Employee
Boy/Girl Next Door
Brother’s Best Friend
Cancer
Captor/Captive
Cheating
Chef
Christmas
Colleagues
Consensual Non-Consent (CNC)
Cozy Romance
Crime
Curvy FMC
Daddy/Baby
Dangerous Attraction
Dark Romance
Death Of A Loved One
Diverse Romance
Divorce/Post Divorce
Doctor/Patient Romance
Doctor/Patient’s Family Member
Dom/Sub
Dominant
Domme/Sub
Dragons
Enemies To Lovers
Erotica
Ex’s Dad
Ex’s Daughter
Ex’s Sister
Exhibitionism
Fairytale Retelling
Fake Relationship
Fall Romance
Famous/Not Famous
Fast Burn
Fated Mates
FFM
Firefighter
Forbidden Romance
Forced Marriage
Forced Proximity
Found Family
Friends To Lovers
Gay Romance
Golden Retriever
Grief
Grumpy MMC
Grumpy/Sunshine
Happy For Now
He Falls First
Historical Romance
Hockey
Holiday Romance
Hotwifing
Inanimate Objects
Independent FMC
Indian
Irish Mafia
Journalist
Kidnapper/Captive
Kink Friendly
Knifeplay
Landlord/Tenant
Law Enforcement
Law Enforcement/Criminal
LGBTQ Romance
Mafia
Masked Stalker
Meet-Cute
Modern Matchmaking
Monarchy
Monk
Morally Gray FMC
Morally Gray MMC
Mystery
Nanny/Parent
Nerds
Nocturne Falls Universe
Nun
One Bed
Paranormal Romance
Pierced MMC
Pleasure Dom
Plus-Size FMC
Polyamory
Possessive Hero
POV – Dual First Person
POV – Dual Third Person
POV – First Person
POV – Multiple First Person
POV – Multiple Third Person
POV – Third Person
Priest/Parishioner
Psychological Thriller
Ranch
Regency Romance
Religious Romance
Religious Trauma
Reverse Harem
Rom-Com
Romantasy
Second Chance
Secret Child
Serial Killer
Sex Club
Sex Worker
Shibari
Shifters
Silver Fox
Single Dad
Single Mom
Sister’s Best Friend
Sister’s Ex
Slow Burn
Small Island Life
Small Town
Sports
Stalker
Step-siblings
Strong FMC
Submissive
Sugar Daddy
Summer Romance
Suspense
Taboo Kinks
Teacher/Parent
Thirst Trap
Thriller
Twins
Twisted Romance
Urban Fantasy
Video Games
Vigilante Justice
Virgin FMC
Voyeurism
Werewolf
Why Choose
Winter
Witch
Wolves
Workplace Romance

Footer